08-06-2014 Budget Workshop_Workers Compensation Overview & Renewal ReviewVILLAGE OF NORTH PALM BEACH
Workers Compensation Overview
1 Re..vi
Re n P w
ew
Presented by:
Ellen Jones, Director - Risk Management
Kurt Gehring, CEO
GET-TRING A GROUP
I N S U R A N C E B R O K E R S A & C 0 N 5 U LTA N T 5
Items for Discussion
• Overview
— Three year rolling claims history
— Experience Modification Factor (Mod.)
Payroll and losses included in formula
Frequency & Severity = Losses
2014 Mod. 1.29
— Safety Reviews
Continued employee involvement
Safety culture emphasis
Training
Presumption claims
2 GEHRING AGROUP
INSURANCE BROKERS/ B CONSULTANTS
Items for Discussion Cont.
• Fiscal Year 2013/2014
— High Renewal Option received from PGIT
$346,125
— Gehring Group obtains FMIT proposal
$261,679
3
GEHRING AGROUP
I N S U R A N C E B R O K E R 5, & C ON S U L T ANTS
Village of North Palm Beach
Florida Municipal Insurance Trust (FMIT)
Workers' Compensation Insurance Proposal
Effective October 1, 2014
F 14 s V RA N L! H M V K:XS.A 10 CG N S L r A N— s
,0 free) z FMIT Proposal
Total Estimated Annual Payroll
$
9,015,359
10,683,515
AR Adjustment
$
(28,791)
Manual Premium
$
402,218
$
424,518
Drug Free Workplace Credit (5%)
$
(19,709)
$
(21,226)
Safety Credit (2%)
$
(8,044
$
(8,430)
Discounted Premium
$
374,465
$
374,4 ,65
Mod Rate - 1.29
$
52,425
$
108,595
Normal Premium
$
426,890
$
483,060
Advance Discount
$
(43,679)
$
(43,679)
Expense Constant
$
200
$
200
Incentive Credit
$
(134,1931
$
(146,486)
Annual Premium
$
2.49,218
$
293,095
Gehring Group Service Fee (5%)*
$
12,461
$
14,655
Annual Net Premium
261,679
$
307,750
S tncreaselDecrease
NIA
46,071
fncreasefDecrease
NIA
19%
T
0
Claims and Insurance Projection
Policy Year 2013/2014 aS July 3o,2o14
— Loss Ratio to Date
— Claims Costs Paid to Date
— Reserves
— Total Incurred Costs /Losses
— Number of Claims to Date
— Average Claims Cost to Date
— Experience Modification Factor
— Shock Claim (1) - Presumption
144%
$149,962
163 139
$313,022
19
$16,474
1.14
$247,500
5 GEHRING AGROUP
I N S U R A N C E B R O K E R 5, & C ON S U L T ANTS
0
Claims and Insurance Projection
Policy Year 2012/2013
— Loss Ratio
— Claims Costs Paid to Date
— Reserves
— Total Incurred Costs /Losses
— Number of Claims to Date
— Average Claims Cost to Date
— Experience Modification Factor
— Major Claims 4 > $45k
125%
$278,998
$43,008
$322,005
35
$9,200
1.02
$214,000
6 GEHRING AGROUP
I N S U R A N C E B R O K E R 5, & C ON S U L T ANTS
11
Claims and Insurance Projection
Policy Year 2011/2012
— Loss Ratio
— Claims Costs Paid to Date
— Reserves
— Total Incurred Costs /Losses
— Number of Claims to Date
— Average Claims Cost to Date
— Experience Modification Factor
— Shock Claim (1)
64%
$114,352
$14,748
$129,100
20
$6,455
.83
$61,000
5 GEHRING AGROUP
I N S U R A N C E B R O K E R 5, & C ON S U L T ANTS
0
Claims and Insurance Projection
Policy Year 2010/2011
— Loss Ratio
— Claims Costs Paid to Date
— Reserves
— Total Incurred Costs /Losses
— Number of Claims to Date
— Average Claims Cost to Date
— Experience Modification Factor
— Shock Claims (1) - Presumption
266
$498,172
$7,625
$505,797
zo
$25,289
.92
$426,000
5 GEHRING AGROUP
I N S U R A N C E B R O K E R 5, & C ON S U L T ANTS
E
Total Incurred Losses by Policy Year
$600,000
$505,797
$500,000
$400,000
$300,000
$200,000
$123,874
$100,000
4'
$0
$129,1,00
i
$322,005 $313,022
2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 2013/14
GEHRING AGROUP
I N 5 U R A N C E B R O K E R 5, & C ON S U L T ANTS
Discussion Quest*ions
GEHRING ,AGROUP
INSURANCE BROKERS/ B CONSULTANTS