04-24-2008 VC REG-MMINUTES OF THE REGULAR SESSION
VILLAGE COUNCIL OF NORTH PALM BEACH, FLORIDA
APRIL 24, 2008
u
•
Present:
ROLL CALL
William Manuel, Mayor
David B. Norris, Vice Mayor
Darryl Aubrey, Sc.D. President Pro Tem
Edward M. Eissey, Ph.D. Councilman
T.R. Hernacki, P.E., Councilman
Jimmy Knight, Village Manager
Leonazd Rubin, Village Attorney
Melissa Teal, CMC, Village Clerk
Mayor Manuel called the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m All members of Council were present.
All members of staff were present.
INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Vice Mayor Norris gave the invocation and President Pro Tem Aubrey led the public in the
Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.
AWARDS AND RECOGNITION
Mayor Manuel proclaimed April 25, 2008 as Arbor Day in the Village ofNorth Palm Beach, and
announced a tree planting ceremony at 9:00 a.m. Friday morning at Osborne Pazk.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
The minutes of the Regulaz Session held 4/10/08 were approved as written.
STATEMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Steve Canfield wncerning the issue.
Steve Hilker, 713 Kittyhawk Way, addressed the Council concerning a problem with speeding
traffic on Kittyhawk Way. Mr. Hilker requested that Council consider installing four speed
bumps on Kittyhawk Way. Mr. Hilker also distributed a letter from neighbor Jennifer Braswell
regarding this matter. Village Manager Jimmy Knight will confer with Public Safety Director
FIRST READING OF ORDINANCE 2008-08 - DOMANI PARCEL LARGE-SCALE
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT
Councilman Hernacki moved that Ordinance 2008-08 entitled
AN ORDINANCE OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF NORTH PALM BEACH,
FLORIDA, ADOPTING ALARGE-SCALE AMENDMENT TO THE VILLAGE COMPREHENSIVE
PLAN RELATING TO A SEVEN ACRE PARCEL OF PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE EAST
SIDE OF U.S. HIGHWAY ONE APPROXIMATELY ONE M[LE SOUTH OF PGA BOULEVARD,
AS MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN ("DOMANI PARCEL"); REMOVING THE
PROPERTY FROM SPECIAL POLICY 5.2 AND ASSIGNING IT A HIGH DENSITY
RESIDENTIAL FUTURE LAND USE DESIGNATION; AMENDING THE VILLAGE FUTURE
LAND USE MAP SERIES; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR
CONFLICTS; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE
be adopted on first reading. Vice Mayor Norris seconded the motion.
Minutes of Village Council Regular Session held April 24, 2008 Page 2 of 5
DOMANI PARCEL LARGE-SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT continued
Village Manager Jimmy Knight advised that Kolter Properties has requested that the Comprehensive Plan
Future Land Use Map be amended to remove the Domani pacel from Special Policy 5.2 and assign it a
high density residential land use classification, which would allow an increase in units from 77 up to a
maximum of 168. Mr. Knight clarified that adopting Ordinance 2008-08 on first reading means that
amendment 07-2.1 will be transmitted to the Florida Dept. of Community Affairs (DCA) for review, and
requires adoption on sewnd reading before the land use change is effective. Mr. Knight reported that the
Planning Commission voted 3 - 2 on 7/24/07 to approve the application as submitted.
Mayor Manuel opened the public hearing.
Robert Mauer, 115 Lakeshore Drive, provided a written statement to the Council, and declared
that designating this parcel high density is premature. Mr. Mauer favored the original plan for
the Domani property, and stated tl-iat traffic patterns for the new proposal have not been cleared
with the Dept. of Transportation. Mr. Mauer expressed wncerns including the visual impact,
density of the lot, and traffic caused by southbound residents. Mr. Mauer was also concerned
with setbacks and felt that a building of 18 stories or higher directly on U.S. Highway 1 creates
an urban environment.
Joe Fagan, 1208 Marine Way, stated that he is President of the closest Property Owner's
Association to the Domani project and represents 186 owners. Mr. Fagan expressed adamant
opposition to increasing the density for the Domani property. Mr. Fagan was concerned with an
increase in traffic and suggested that because the entrance to the Domani project will be directly
across U.S. Highway 1 from the Benjamin School, it will require a traffic light.
Patricia Freedman, 1200 Marine Way, advised that the Old Port Cove Property Owner's
Association as a whole is concerned with the change in density. Mrs. Freedman stated that it
would have an adverse impact on traffic congestion, particularly during rush hour from 4:30 p.m.
to 6:00 p.m. and during bridge openings.
There being no further public com...ents, Mayor Manuel closed the public hearing.
Village Attorney Len Rubin advised that the land is zoned R-3 and Council is determining whether
high density residential is an appropriate category for this parcel. Mr. Rubin noted that if the
comprehensive plan amendment is not approved, the land is still subject to Special Policy 5.2,
which caps density at 11 units per acre; however, if the amendment is adopted and enacted on
second reading, Kolter will submit a new planned unit development (PUD) application specifying
appearance, height, number of units, etc. Mr. Rubin advised that Council may still consider
density during the PUD process and is not obligated to approve the maximum 24 units per acre.
Village Planning Consultant Jim Fleischmann discussed the issue of density, and noted that the
adjoining development, Old Port Cove, ranges from 9 units per acre up to 43 units per acre.
Mr. Fleischmann advised that the entne Old Port Cove acreage, including the marina parcels and
commercial parcel, divided by total number of units, equals 21.5 units per acre; or, if only the
residential parcels are considered, equals a density of 25 units per acre.
Mr. Fleischmann asked for Council direction on whether to request DCA review of the amendment
or no review. Mr. Fleischmann estimated that if there is no review, it will take 90 days after
transmittal before the proposed amendment is returned for Council wnsideration on second reading.
Mr. Fleischmann advised that if DCA review is requested, DCA will issue an Objections,
Recommendations, and Comments report, which could take up to a maximum of 155 days.
Mr. Fleischmann noted it is unlikely that DCA will comment on height and density issues.
Minutes of Village Council Regular Session held Apri124, 2008 Page 3 of 5
DOMANI PARCEL LARGE-SCALE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN AMENDMENT continued
Discussion ensued on the number of stories allowed east and west of U.S. Highway 1, north of
Parker Bridge, as well as zoning districts R-2 and R-3.
Mr. Fleischmann noted that the U.S. Highway 1 Corridor Study recommended that all residential
parcels north of Parker Bridge be assigned a high density future land use designation.
Discussion ensued on Amendment 07-2.1, page 3-5, item B.S, Land Use Projections, with
reference to the year 2010. Mr. Fleischmann explained that the planning time-frame of the
current Comprehensive Plan is 2010, with the assumption that the Village would attain buildout
during that period. Mr. Fleischmann is presently writing the Evaluation and Appraisal Report
(EAR) based amendments to the Comprehensive Plan, which will extend that period to 2014.
Ryan Thomas of Bohler Engineering, and Bob Vail and John Csapo of Kolter Properties were
present. Mr. Thomas explained that Kolter is presently approved for 77 units and is seeking a
change to allow up to 168 units. Mr. Thomas gave a presentation on the project. Mr. Thomas
discussed preliminary traffic studies and advised that the configuration of the driveway is set by
FDOT. Mr. Thomas reported that the driveway is centered in the middle of the property and
allows left-in from the north, right-in from the south and right-out, with no left-out. Mr. Thomas
noted that the increase in density v/ill result in an increase of 18 trips per peak hour to the north
and 12 trips per peak hour to the south.
It was requested that Kolter provide a progressive display of plans and report on the length of
time for construction ofthe project during the interim between first and second reading.
Thereafter, the motion to adopt and enact Ordinance 2008-08 on first reading passed with all
present voting aye. By consensus, Council requested that DCA review the proposed amendment.
CONSENT AGENDA
Councilman Eissey moved to approve the consent agenda. Vice Mayor Norris seconded the
motion, which passed unanimously. The following items were approved:
Receive Minutes of Recreation Advisory Board meeting held 4/8/08
Receive Minutes of Audit Committee meeting held 4/9/08
RESOLUTION 2008-27 ADOPTED -COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT
Councilman Eissey moved that Resolution 2008-27 entitled
A RESOLUTION OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF NORTH PALM
BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING AN INTERLOCAL COOPERATION AGREEMENT
WITH PALM BEACH COUNTY FOR PARTICIPATION IN THE URBAN COUNTY
PROGRAM TO ACCESS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT AND HOME
INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIPS PROGRAM FUNDS; AUTHORIZING THE MAYOR AND
VILLAGE CLERK TO EXECUTE THE AGREEMENT; AND PROVIDING FOR AN
EFFECTIVE DATE
be adopted. Councilman Hernacki seconded the motion, which passed unanimously.
Minutes of Village Council Regular Session held April 24, 2008 Page 4 of 5
RESOLUTION 2008-28 ADOPTED - APPOINTING MEMBERS TO VILLAGE BOARDS
Councilman Hernacki moved that Emery Newell and Robert Gebbia be appointed to the Audit
Committee. President Pro Tem Aubrey seconded the motion, which passed unanimously.
By written ballot, the original of which is attached to the minutes of record, the Council
appointed Frank Manning and Rick Stanish to the Code Enforcement Board.
President Pro Tem Aubrey moved tc reappoint the four candidates to the Construction Board of
Adjustment and Appeals. Vice P~Iayor Norris seconded the motion, which passed unanimously.
By written ballot, the original of which is attached to the minutes of record, the Council
appointed Mary Annis, Natalie McKenna, Christine DelGuzzi, Peter Carvajal, and Robert Mauer
to the Library Advisory Board.
Councilman Hernacki moved to appoint Kris Garrison as a regular member and Tim Hullihan as
an alternate member to the Planning Commission. The motion died for lack of a second.
President Pro Tem Aubrey moved to reappoint the four incumbent members on the Planning
Commission. Vice Mayor Norris seconded the motion, and all present voted aye.
Vice Mayor Norris moved to appoint Dianna Craven as 1st alternate to the Recreation Advisory
Board. Councilman Eissey seconded the motion, which passed unanimously.
By written ballot, the original of which is attached to the minutes of record, the Council
appointed Bob Bell, Donald Grill, and Chris Cantwell to the Recreation Advisory Board.
Vice Mayor Norris moved to appoint Jay Carron as a regular member and Denise Whiteford as
the 1st alternate to the Waterways Board. Councilman Eissey seconded the motion, and all
present voted aye.
By written ballot, the original of which is attached to the minutes of record, the Council
appointed Jerry Sullivan as 2nd alternate to the Waterways Board.
By written ballot, the original of which is attached to the minutes of record, the Council
appointed Dianne Reeves, Ted Bukowski, and Keith Davis to the Zoning Board of Adjustment.
Thereafter, the names of all those appointed were entered into Resolution 2008-28.
Vice Mayor Norris moved that Resolution 2008-28 entitled:
A RESOLUTION OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF NORTH PALM
BEACH, FLORIDA, APPOINTING MEMBERS TO THE AUDIT COMMITTEE, CODE
ENFORCEMENT BOARD, CONSTRUCTION BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT AND APPEALS,
COUNTRY CLUB ADVISORY BOARD, LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD, PLANNING
COMMISSION, RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD, WATERWAYS BOARD, AND
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE
be adopted. Councilman Eissey seconded the motion, which passed unanimously
COUNCIL MATTERS
Mayor Manuel congratulated the North Palm Beach Women's Golf Team for winning the Palm
Beach County Women's League for the second year.
Minutes of Village Council Regular Session held Apri124, 2008 Page 5 of 5
COUNCIL MATTERS continued
Mayor Manuel recognized the Support Our Troops volunteers, who recently shipped 1,232
pounds to our fostered unit in Iraq and have raised enough funds for all 188 soldiers to receive
prepaid calling cards.
Mayor Manuel acknowledged receipt of a letter from the local American Cancer Society Relay
for Life representative expressing thanks to the Council and Administration in promoting the
18-hour Relay for Life, which takes place this weekend at Jupiter High School.
Mayor Manuel announced the upcoming Palm Beach County League of Cities Gala Installation
Luncheon on 5/23/08.
VILLAGE MANAGER MATTERS
Mr. Knight announced a staffbudget retreat tomorrow and advised that the proposed FY 2009 Budget
will be submitted to Council on July 10th Mr. Knight requested that councilmen contact him
concerning the proposed schedule for Budget Workshops, if there are conflicts on any of the dates.
Regarding architectural plans for the new tennis facility, Mr. Knight reported that a proposed
contract has been delivered to Brian Idle.
Mr. Knight thanked residents who spoke on behalf of the Public Safety Department to the
Commission for Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies (CALEA.)
Mr. Knight reviewed golf statistics, including summer memberships, rounds of play, and revenue
Mr. Knight gave an update on the Request For Qualifications (RFQ) for Village engineering
services and noted the receipt of 18 submissions from interested firms. Mr. Knight advised a
staff committee will meet Wednesday, April 30th at 8:00 a.m. to review and rank the
submissions, with a shortlist of applicants tentatively scheduled to make presentations at the
Council's May 8th Regular Session.
REPORTS OF SPECIAL COMMITTEES AND ADVISORY BOARDS
Audit Committee Chairman Tom Magill presented the Annual Report of the Audit Committee.
Mayor Manuel thanked the Audit Committee for their diligent work on behalf of the Village.
ADJOURNMENT
With no further business to come before the Council, the meeting adjourned at 9:11 p.m.
~0~~9~~~ ~'~~~
Melissa Teal, CMC, Village Clerk
CLERK'S TALLY SHEET
LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD
April 24, 2008
•
Vacancies: 5 total (3 regular & 2 alternates)
Round 1 Round 2
Annis, Mary (I)
Carvajal, Peter (I)
DelGu~i, Christine (I) LLCM
McKenna, Natalie (I)
Mauer, Robert ~
Rogers, Louva
(Signs ure)
T
/
-1~~~~~
~
,
(Signature)
Round 3
•
•
BALLOT
LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 5 total (3 regular & 2 alternates)
Annis, Mary (I)
Carvajal, Peter (I)
DelGuai, Christine (I)
McKenna, Natalie (I)
Mauer, Robert
Rogers, Louva
Rou d 1/ Round 2
~~ ~~
(Signature)
Round 3
•
•
BALLOT
LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 5 total (3 regular ~ 2 alternates)
Round
Annis, Mary (I)
Carvajal, Peter (I)
DelGuai, Christine (I)
McKenna, Natalie (I)
Mauer, Robert
Round 2 Round 3
•
Rogers, Louva
u
BALLOT
LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 5 total (3 regular ~ 2 alternates)
Round 1 Round 2
Annis, Mary (I) ~
Carvajal, Peter (I) ~(
DelGuai, Christine (I)
McKenna, Natalie (I)
Mauer, Robert
Rogers, Louva
ignature)
Round 3
•
~ ~ BALLOT
LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD
April 24, 2008
•
Vacancies: 5 total (3 regular S 2 alternates)
Annis, Mary (I)
Carvajal, Peter (I)
DelGuai, Christine (I)
McKenna, Natalie (I)
Mauer, Robert
Rogers, Louva
(Si nature)
Round 1 Round 2
Round 3
•
~ BALLOT
LIBRARY ADVISORY BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 5 total (3 regular & 2 alternates)
Round 1 Round 2
•
Annis, Mary (I) ~
Carvajal, Peter (I)
DelGuai, Christine (I) ~
McKenna, Natalie (I) ~
Mauer, Robert
Rogers, Louva
C/
(Signature)
Round 3
•
CLERK'S TALLY SHEET
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular and 2 alternates)
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Brown, Ted
Bukowski, Ted (I) ~~
Davis, Keith (I)
Reeves, Dianne (I)
•
(Signature)
~~~~~ /mom
(Signature)
•
BALLOT
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular and 2 alternates)
Round 1
Brown, Ted
Bukowski, Ted (I) ~/
Davis, Keith (I) l/
Reeves, Dianne (I)
•
(Signature)
Round 2 Round 3
•
BALLOT
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular and 2 alternates)
R~~ ~nri 1
Brown, Ted
Bukowski, Ted (I)
Davis, Keith (I)
Reeves, Dianne (I)
•
Round 2 Round 3
•
BALLOT
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular and 2 alternates)
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Brown, Ted
Bukowski, Ted (I) _~
Davis, Keith (I) ~
Reeves, Dianne (I) /~
•
O O
(Signatur
•
BALLOT
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular and 2 alternates)
Round 1
Brown, Ted
Bukowski, Ted (I)
Davis, Keith (I)
Reeves, Dianne (I)
•
Round 2 Round 3
BALLOT
•
ZONING BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular and 2 alternates)
Round 1
Brown, Ted
Bukowski, Ted (I) ~
Davis, Keith (I) ~
Reeves, Dianne (I)
(_~~~'!
V (Signature)
Round 2 Round 3
u
CLERK'S TALLY SHEET
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 2
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Manning, Frank (I) f ~ / ~
Moore, Ed (I) /
Stanish, Rick / l /
~%`~e~
• (Signature)
(Signaturre)
•
BALLOT
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
•
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 2
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1
Manning, Frank (I) !///
Moore, Ed (I) (/
Stanish, Rick
G%4 ~,-~
(Signature)
Round 2 Round 3
•
BALLOT
u
•
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 2
(I) =Incumbent
Ro~
Manning, Frank (I)
Moore, Ed (I)
Stanish, Rick
Round 2 Round 3
BALLOT
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 2
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Manning, Frank (I) ~
Moore, Ed (I)
Stanish, Rick
6~
• (Signs
•
BALLOT
•
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 2
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Manning, Frank (I)
Moore, Ed (I) t /
Stanish, Rick V
_ i~~2:~
(SVgnature)
•
BALLOT
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 2
(I) =Incumbent
Manning, Frank (I)
Moore, Ed (I)
Stanish, Rick
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
(Signature)
•
C~
CLERK'S TALLY SHEET
RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
April 24 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (2 regular ~ 1 alternate)
Round 1 Round 2
Bell, Bob (I) ~_
Cantwell, Chris ~ /I /
Craven, Dianna (I)
Grenier, Sylvain ~ ~
Grill, Donald (I)
Liss, Carolyn
Ring, Ted
(Signature) ~
~~ ~ /~~
s%" E re)
Round 3
•
BALLOT
RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
April 24 2008
•
Vacancies: 3 total (2 regular 81 alternate)
Bell, Bob (I)
Cantwell, Chris
Craven, Dianna (I)`'~D9
Grenier, Sylvain
Grill, Donald (I)
Liss, Carolyn
Ring, Ted
Round 1 ,
Round 2 Round 3
~ ~~
v
~~ `~ `~
(Signature)
•
•
BALLOT
RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
April 24 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (2 regular ~ 1 alternate)
Round Round 2
Bell, Bob (I) -
Cantwell, Chris
Craven, Dianna (I)
Grenier, Sylvain /
Grill, Donald (I) V
Liss, Carolyn
Ring, Ted
Round 3
•
u
BALLOT
RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
April 24 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (2 regular 81 alternate)
Round 1
Round 2
Round 3
Bell, Bob (I) /
Cantwell, Chris
Craven, Dianna (I)
Grenier, Sylvain
Grill, Donald (I) ~
Liss, Carolyn '~
Ring, Ted
(Sig at
•
•
BALLOT
RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
April 24 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (2 regular & 1 alternate)
Round 1 Round 2
Bell, Bob (I)
Cantwell, Chris V
Craven, Dianna (I) ~~
Grenier, Sylvain ~
Grill, Donald (I) V
Liss, Carolyn
Ring, Ted
.~~'
(Signat re)
Round 3
u
•
BALLOT
RECREATION ADVISORY BOARD
April 24 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (2 regular $1 alternate)
Bell, Bob (I)
Cantwell, Chris
Craven, Dianna (I)
Grenier, Sylvain
Grill, Donald (I)
Liss, Carolyn
Ring, Ted
Round 1 Round 2
®~ND / ~~zar~
/~
(Signature)
Round 3
•
~J
•
•
CLERK'S TALLY SHEET
WATERWAYS BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular ~ 2 alternates)
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1
Batchelor, Chuck
Brown, Ted ~
Carron, Jay (I)
Falvey, Kevin
Polin, Ronald
Preti, Ed
Ring, Ted
Schlechter, Barbara
Sullivan, Jeny 1~
Wallen, Rodney
Wendt, Charles
Whiteford, Denise (I)
Wood, William
_ ~_ ~~
(Signature
(Signature)
Round 2 Round 3
BALLOT
u
WATERWAYS BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular ~ 2 alternates)
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1
Batchelor, Chuck
Brown, Ted
Carron, Jay (I)
Falvey, Kevin
Polin, Ronald
Preti, Ed
Ring, Ted
Schlechter, Barbara
Sullivan, Jeny
Wallen, Rodney
Wendt, Charles
Whiteford, Denise (I)
Wood, William
(Signature)
Round 2 Round 3
•
L J
BALLOT
WATERWAYS BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular 8 2 alternates)
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1
Batchelor, Chuck
Brown, Ted
Carron, Jay (I)
Falvey, Kevin
Polin, Ronald
Preti, Ed
Ring, Ted
Schlechter, Barbara
Sullivan, Jerry
Wallen, Rodney
Wendt, Charles
Whiteford, Denise (I)
Wood, William
Round 2 Round 3
•
BALLOT
WATERWAYS BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular ~ 2 alternates)
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Batchelor, Chuck
Brown, Ted
Canon, Jay (I)
Falvey, Kevin
Polin, Ronald
• Preti, Ed
Ring, Ted /
Schlechter, Barbara
Sullivan, Jeny
Wallen, Rodney
Wendt, Charles
Whiteford, Denise (I)
Wood, William
~'" l'~ i
(Signs
•
BALLOT
WATERWAYS BOARD
• April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular & 2 alternates)
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1 Round 2 Round 3
Batchelor, Chuck
Brown, Ted
Carron, Jay (I)
Falvey, Kevin
Polin, Ronald
• Preti, Ed
Ring, Ted
Schlechter, Barbara
Sullivan, Jerry
Wallen, Rodney
Wendt, Charles
Whiteford, Denise (I)
Wood, William
•
BALLOT
WATERWAYS BOARD
April 24, 2008
Vacancies: 3 total (1 regular S 2 alternates)
(I) =Incumbent
Round 1
Batchelor, Chuck
Brown, Ted
Carron, Jay (I)
Falvey, Kevin
Polin, Ronald
Preti, Ed
Ring, Ted
Schlechter, Barbara
Sullivan, Jerry ~ ~~ '~
Wallen, Rodney
Wendt, Charles
Whiteford, Denise (I)
Wood, William
r~ J
(Signature)
Round 2 Round 3
•